Traded in, sold or paid off? You may be owed refunds.
Add-ons are usually charged once, up front, and rolled into the loan. When the loan ends early, the unused part of GAP and credit insurance is usually owed back, a service contract or a tire and wheel plan can usually be cancelled for a prorated refund, and prepaid maintenance depends on its contract and the visits you have used.
What ends with the loan. GAP and credit life or disability insurance protect the loan, so they have no value once the loan is paid off. Their unused part is usually owed back.
What you can cancel early. A service contract (extended warranty), tire and wheel protection and prepaid maintenance cover the car, not the loan, so they don't end by themselves. You can usually cancel a service contract or tire and wheel plan and get a prorated refund of the unused part. Prepaid maintenance depends on its contract and the visits you have used.
When the loan is already paid off, the refund goes to you. These refunds are often not paid automatically. In its 2024 review of auto lenders, the CFPB found refunds that were never made, figured from the wrong date, or delayed for months. So ask for them.
How to ask
- Find the contracts from the purchase: the GAP agreement, the service contract, the tire and wheel plan, any prepaid maintenance. Each names who handles cancellations.
- Contact who the contract names: usually the plan's administrator or the selling dealer's finance office. For GAP on some loans it is the lender.
- Send the contract or plan number, the date the loan was paid off or the car was sold or traded in, and the odometer reading on that date. The letter below has room for all of it.
- Keep a copy, ask for the refund amount in writing, and follow up if it doesn't arrive.
A letter to copy
Fill in the brackets, keep a copy, and send it the way the contract asks.
[Your name] [Your mailing address] [Date] To: [The plan administrator or the dealer finance office named on your contract] Re: Cancellation of [product name, for example the service contract or GAP] Please cancel the contract below and refund the unearned portion. Name on the contract: [Your name] Contract or plan number: [Number] Vehicle: [Year, make and model] VIN: [17-character VIN] Cancellation date: [The date the loan was paid off or the car was sold or traded in, or today if you still own the car] Odometer reading on that date: [Miles] Please send the refund to me. If the loan on this vehicle is still open, please send it to the lender and tell me when it was sent. Please confirm in writing that the contract is cancelled, the refund amount, how it was figured and any fee taken out. Thank you, [Your name] [Phone or email]
The refund is the unused part, not the full price, usually minus a cancellation fee. For a service contract, some states cap the fee (California: the lesser of 10% or $25; Illinois: the lesser of 10% or $50). A claim already paid can reduce or end the refund. Your contract sets the exact rules. This is general information, not legal advice.
Buying the next car?
Product by product
| Product | Ends with the loan? | Cancel early? | What you usually get back |
|---|---|---|---|
| Service contract (extended warranty) | No, it covers the car | Yes | The full price in the free-look window with no claim, then a prorated refund minus a fee |
| GAP insurance or GAP waiver | Yes | Yes | A prorated refund of the unused part in most contracts |
| Credit life or disability insurance | Yes | Yes | The unearned premium, under state insurance law |
| Tire and wheel protection | No, it covers the car | Yes, under its contract | Usually like a service contract: full early on, then prorated, possibly minus a fee |
| Prepaid maintenance | No, it covers the car | Under its contract | Depends on the contract and the visits you have used |
| Coatings, etching, nitrogen, film, tint, trackers | No | Usually not, once applied | Usually nothing once applied |
Deciding whether a product is worth buying in the first place: every dealer add-on, explained and when GAP and extended warranties are worth it.
Some states set the rules by law
A few examples where a statute or a state agency says it plainly. Other states differ, and where no law sets a rule, your contract does.
California service contracts
A full refund within 60 days (30 days for a used car without a manufacturer's warranty), then a prorated refund. The cancellation fee is capped at the lesser of 10% or $25. On a financed contract the refund can go to you, the lender or both.
Washington service contracts
A full refund with no fee within 9 days; from day 10 to 30 days, the full price minus a fee of up to $25; a prorated refund after that.
Illinois service contracts
A full refund within 30 days if no service has been provided, then a prorated refund. The cancellation fee is capped at the lesser of 10% or $50.
California GAP waivers
Cancelled within 30 days, a full refund; later, a prorated refund. No cancellation fee is allowed, and there is no refund after a total loss the waiver paid.
Reviewed November 3, 2026. This is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
- Can I cancel my extended warranty after buying a car?
- Usually, yes. Most service contracts can be cancelled at any time: inside the free-look window, often 30 to 60 days, you usually get the full price back if you haven't made a claim, and after that a prorated refund, usually minus a fee. Your contract sets the exact window and fee, and some states set them by law.
- Do I get my GAP insurance back when I trade in my car?
- GAP ends when the loan is paid off, so when you trade in, sell or refinance, the unused part is usually owed back on a prorated basis. It is often not refunded automatically, so contact whoever the GAP contract names (the administrator, the dealer's finance office or, on some loans, the lender) with the payoff date and ask for it.
- Does a warranty refund lower my car payment?
- No. When the warranty was financed and the loan is still open, the refund usually goes to the lender and comes off the loan balance. The payment stays the same; the loan just ends sooner. If the loan is already paid off, the refund goes to you.
- Can I get a refund on paint protection?
- Usually not once it has been applied, because the product has been used. If it was on your paperwork without your agreement, raise it with the dealer in writing: the FTC's September 2026 guidance for dealers says a dealer should have a buyer's express, informed consent before charging for an add-on.
Sources
- ReferenceCFPB: Supervisory Highlights, Issue 35, auto finance special edition (Fall 2024)
- ReferenceNerdWallet: How to cancel an extended car warranty
- ReferenceExperian: Can you get a refund on GAP insurance?
- ReferenceNevada NRS 690A.097: refund of credit insurance premium
- SellerLexus Financial Services: Tire and Wheel Protection disclosure
- ReferenceCalifornia Civil Code 1794.41
- ReferenceWashington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner: Extended warranties and service contracts
- ReferenceIllinois 215 ILCS 152/35
- ReferenceCalifornia Civil Code 2982.12
- ReferenceFTC: Automobile Industry Pricing Transparency: FAQs (Sep 2026)
Last reviewed November 3, 2026. General information from the sources above, not legal advice. Your contract sets the exact window, the fee and who to contact.
